Transgendered teacher, Catholic school in a legal duel
Charlie Butts - OneNewsNow - 10/23/2009 4:00:00 AMBookmark and Share

CanadaA complaint has been filed by a transgendered substitute teacher against a Catholic school board in Canada.

 

Jan Buterman was a substitute teacher for St. Albert Catholic Schools in Edmonton, Alberta, before announcing that she was going through the process to become a "he." Dave Quist, executive director of the Institute of Marriage and Family - Canada, offers insight on the incident.
 
"The Catholic school board looked at it and said that [the gender change] was – quote – 'not aligned with the teachings of the church and would create confusions and complexit[ies] with students and parents as a model and witness to Catholic faith values,'" he explains. "Therefore they removed her from the substitute teacher list."
 
transgender symbolButerman has since filed a complaint before the Alberta Human Rights Tribunal for her dismissal -- and reports that in the midst of her challenge to the Catholic school board, there are other secular schools where she might apply. She argues that public employers do not have a right to make employment decisions based on tenets of faith.
 
Quist explains that the Catholic Church operates some public schools for the government "and receives public funds based on the number of children that they have in their classrooms -- and so they are receiving public tax dollars." In light of this, however, Quist argues that when parents sign their children up to attend a school within the Catholic school district, "they know exactly what they're going into."
 
The outcome of the case is uncertain because of other rulings by the Tribunal that outraged many Canadians -- meaning that members might be wary of that in approaching the Buterman complaint.

 

iTunes Podcast

 

Rate this Story (1 Star = Not so Good -and- 5 Stars = Excellent!)

  (average 4 out of 5)


View Comments

Other Stories in Legal and Courts
Senate confirms controversial judge to federal bench
Lawsuit requests people's voice
NJ teen barred from abortion protest sues school
Congressman bribes way into 13-year prison sentence
Supreme Court ignores free speech
ACORN's root for suit?
Terror trials in NYC criticized
ADF pushes for 14th Ft. Hood victim
Churches win in equal access debate
Michigan abortionist under pressure
Commissioners' prayer leads to federal court
1st Amendment shoved aside on Constitution Day
Founder takes charity to court
'Opt out' not an option, says judge
Planned Parenthood seeks silence, fails
Audits on free exercise of religion?
ACLU mum on this church-gov't lawsuit
Christian organization wins attorney’s fees
Courts deem pro-life groups lack standing
ACLU accused of promoting promiscuous lifestyle


If you believe OneNewsNow.com is an important source for Christian news,
please consider a
 
small tax-deductible gift for this service. 





11/20/2009 8:56:29 PM