Democrats mandate - coverage or taxes
Jim Brown - OneNewsNow - 11/6/2009 9:25:00 AMBookmark and Share

The ranking Republican on the Senate Finance Committee believes the individual mandate included in Democrats' healthcare bill is an unconstitutional overreach of government.

 

Health care moneyIndividuals are required to purchase health insurance under the Democrats' healthcare bill, or they will face a tax penalty of 2.5 percent of income.  Employers are required to buy insurance for their employees or pay a penalty of 8 percent of payroll.
 
However, some critics of the legislation argue that auditing self-insured employers and mandating that people buy insurance is beyond the authority of the federal government, and therefore it is unconstitutional.
 
Senator GrassleySenator Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) agrees, but notes there is no legal precedent that would indicate how the Supreme Court may rule on the matter.
 
"Starting with a philosophy that the federal government is a government of limited power - they can't do anything that's not in the Constitution, and the states can do anything that's not prohibited in the Constitution - then I can say that under the Tenth Amendment, the federal government doesn't have the authority to make you buy anything or keep you from buying anything," regards Grassley.  "And particularly that's true of guns now because we recently had a Supreme Court [ruling] in that particular case of guns."
 
Grassley says states could require people to purchase health insurance, as they do car insurance, because states have broader legislative authority than the federal government does.

 

iTunes Podcast

 

Rate this Story (1 Star = Not so Good -and- 5 Stars = Excellent!)

  (average 4.5 out of 5)


View Comments


Other Stories in Politics and Government
U.N. says the world needs fewer children
Spat over mammography guidelines - gov't healthcare at work?
Christian leader fights for public vote on DC gay marriage
Indiana senator shifts left to support Hamilton
'No' to Jesus, 'yes' to Allah
Ohio rep. wants to legalize same-sex marriage
New Hampshire seeks voice
Palin, Winfrey talk about book and Levi Johnston
Votes still being counted in NY special election
Does ACORN trail lead to White House?
RNC will drop abortion coverage
Gold rises, dollar drops
Risky for gov't to subsidize hirings
Is Stupak Amendment effective?
Take from the rich, give to the gov't
WA vote to protect marriage fails, harassment follows
New effort to undermine marriage doomed
Going with the 'real deal' over 'wrong direction'
County censures 'rogue' Republican
Stupak amendment: 'Terrible defeat' for pro-lifers


If you believe OneNewsNow.com is an important source for Christian news,
please consider a
 
small tax-deductible gift for this service. 





11/21/2009 7:09:54 AM