Nursing career nearly ends over homeschool diploma

Sunday, August 7, 2016
Michael F. Haverluck (

No admittance signA high school graduate’s aspiring career as a nurse nearly ended before it began when a hospital in Detroit, Mich., told her that the homeschool diploma she provided was unacceptable.

Mercy Stevenson, who graduated with a high school diploma in 2012, was reportedly the victim of diploma discrimination for the sole reason that she was homeschooled — even though her education records were a clear testimony to her academic excellence.

Fighting for Stevenson’s equal opportunity to become a nurse, the Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA) maintains that there was no logical or legal reason why the Detroit Medical Center could be justified in turning the homeschool grad down.

“Mercy Stevenson enrolled in a university nursing program on the strength of her homeschool transcript, which included two years of community college,” HSLDA reports. “She excelled in her studies, becoming an honors student, and was offered a job this summer as a nurse extern at the Detroit Medical Center.”

No conventional diploma, no job

The rationalization given by the medical center for not accepting Stevenson into their summer nurse extern program essentially made the statement that homeschoolers not participating in a verified co-op are precluded from landing the job — an explanation that did not settle well with the former homeschooler and her parents.

“Despite Mercy’s excellent academic record, the medical center’s recruiter informed Mercy that only a diploma from the state of Michigan or from a verified homeschool co-op would suffice to prove her high school graduation and enable her to start work,” HSLDA Staff Attorney Mike Donnelly explained. “Given a rapidly looming deadline and the recruiter’s obstinacy, Mercy’s parents knew it was time [to seek legal advice on the matter].”

Experiencing the same difficulty from the Detroit Medical Center that Stevenson underwent, HSLDA’s attorneys were told by the recruiter that she would not receive any documentation that was not personally delivered to her over the matter.

As a result, Donnelly immediately wrote a detailed letter to the recruiter because Stevenson was scheduled to meet with her the following day. He promptly overnighted the letter to Stevenson in order for her to be able to hand-deliver it to her recruiter when showing up for their meeting.

In Donnelly’s letter, he readily explained the Michigan state homeschool law and made it clear how Stevenson exceeded the requirements for the position.

“[Mercy had already provided documentation to demonstrate her completion of] far more than a high school education,” Donnelly pointed out to the recruiter in the letter.

Problem solved

HSLDA soon reported that its explanation of the matter was well received by the medical center.

“The recruiter, after meeting with Mercy and receiving her diploma, her transcripts and HSLDA’s letter, acknowledged Mercy’s high school graduation,” the nonprofit Christian legal group announced. “Mercy started her job a week later.”

The mother of Mercy, Jennifer Stevenson, initially thought years ago that she would never be in need of legal assistance regarding homeschooling her daughter because she lives in a part of the country where homeschooling is relatively common.

“Michigan has few regulations and we live in an area with a huge community of homeschoolers,” the homeschool mom shared. “It never crossed my mind that we would have problems with an employer, especially after the kids were in college.”

The home educator is certain that the Detroit Medical Center would not have budged if she did not have the assistance of an experienced team of legal experts at her and her daughter’s side.

“[Without legal representation] the DMC would have rescinded their offer and Mercy would be looking for a new job!” Jennifer Stevenson insisted.

Attorneys at the pro-family Virginia-based legal group warn that even though most colleges and employers across the United States welcome homeschooled graduates, there are still a handful of academic institutions, organizations and companies that harbor bias and ignorance, resulting in discrimination against those with parent-issued diplomas.

We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details




What's your reaction to Trump's proposal to slash in half U.S. contributions to the U.N.?





  Ellison says Dems must fight Republicans at all levels
  Self-inflicted collapse chokes GOP effort to undo Obamacare
  Arrests after scuffle breaks out at California Trump rally
  Storms destroy church, homes in week of turbulent weather
  Vegas Strip reopens after gunman surrender, fatal shooting
Health care defeat is a brutal loss for Speaker Paul Ryan
Some win and some lose with 'Obamacare' still around
Saudi embassy confirms UK attacker had been in Saudi Arabia


Divided GOP makes dismantling ObamaCare little more than campaign promise
US lawmakers urge India to Lift restrictions on Christian charity Compassion International
Trump v. Dems on Russia: Are both sides wrong?
Stunning testimonial from rape victim whose baby is 'an angel'
With health bill dead, Trump, Republicans turn to taxes


Cartoon of the Day


Gov't not helping students clean up their ACT scores

pencil tipAn education analyst maintains that she is not surprised that the majority of high school graduates taking the American College Testing (ACT) college readiness test failed to hit the benchmark in the core subjects tested.