At stake: America's core value of religious freedom

Tuesday, December 5, 2017
Steve Jordahl (

U.S. Supreme CourtThe head of a North Carolina seminary argues that a Supreme Court ruling in a case involving a Christian baker will determine if "weaponizing" the government against its own citizens is the direction the nation will pursue.

A high-profile case before the U.S. Supreme Court today – Masterpiece Cakeshop v. the Colorado Civil Rights Commission – is predicted to be a landmark case on the First Amendment rights of free speech and religious freedom. The Associated Press reports that Justice Anthony Kennedy, who is considered to be the "swing vote" in the ultimate ruling, voiced "competing concerns" during today's oral arguments.

In July 2012, a same-sex couple walked into Masterpiece Cakeshop in Lakewood, Colorado, and asked owner Jack Phillips for a custom wedding cake. Phillips had no problem serving Charlie Craig and David Mullins – in fact, he had done so several times before. But what the Christian baker politely refused to do was to use his artistry to support a same-sex "marriage" ceremony. Craig and Mullins sued Phillips under the state's anti-discrimination law.

"Jack [Phillips] is on the front lines for us all as we desire to live in a truly free society tolerant of a biblical worldview."

Dr. Jerry A. Johnson, President & CEO
National Religious Broadcasters

"[Jack] Phillips does not discriminate against anyone because of who they are. He serves all customers – he just doesn't communicate all messages, namely those that violate his conscience. And the government should not force him to do so."

Monica Burke, research assistant
The Heritage Foundation

"... Viewpoints, messages, and speech can be expressed in many forms – including the creation of a cake for a ceremony. Public accommodation laws are used to protect people against unequal treatment, not to force citizens to participate and then endorse an activity with which they disagree."

Jonathan Alexandre, director of public policy
Liberty Counsel

Dr. Richard Land is the former head of the Southern Baptist Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission and now president of Southern Evangelical Seminary in North Carolina.

Land, Dr. Richard (SBC, ERLC)"[Jack Phillips] said he would bake them a cake," Land begins. "He just didn't feel that he could lend his expertise – his talent, which he believes comes from God – to celebrate that which he finds morally unconscionable."

Colorado found Philips guilty of discrimination, and the case finally was heard this morning in the highest court in the U.S. But according to Land, it's about so much more than cakes.

"It's about conscience and religious freedom," he explains. "It's about the most basic core values of the American experiment – the belief that we have freedom of conscience and freedom of faith."

The prosecution says the First Amendment doesn't apply because the anti-discrimination laws Phillips allegedly broke target conduct, not speech. Land says if the particulars were changed, many who are so certain Phillips is nothing more than a homophobic bigot might change their minds.

"It's no different than requiring a Muslim butcher to provide pork sausage to a customer, even though Muslims believe that pork is something they're not to touch," he suggests.

He says the religious freedom of all believers is at stake. "It's one thing to say that you're going to make same-sex marriage legal – [but] it's another thing to say that we're going to weaponize our own government against its own citizens and say We want to compel you to affirm it."

The Supreme Court's is expected to announce its decision in the case by late June.

Consider Supporting Us?

The staff at strives daily to bring you news from a biblical perspective. If you benefit from this platform and want others to know about it please consider a generous gift today.



We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details




Do you still support the House-led GOP after it pushed through the $1.3 trillion spending bill?





McMaster out, Bolton in as Trump's national security adviser
China may hike tariffs on US pork, aluminum, other goods
Communist Party will regulate China's media, film industry
Life support ending for 'brain dead' school shooting victim
Man convicted of fatal bombing 29 years ago to be executed
Nigeria says just 1 schoolgirl left in hands of Boko Haram
Nor'easter rolls into New England as millions begin cleanup


'No evidence of collusion'! House intel clears Trump in its Russia probe
John Bolton to replace H.R. McMaster as White House national security adviser, Trump says
Donor says he gave illegal contributions to New York mayor, de Blasio, who was aware
Watch: Dad explodes on idiot principal for letting kids, 12, hold anti-gun walkout
Obama directive easing school discipline for minority students fueling classroom chaos


Cartoon of the Day


CA a 'sanctuary' for illegal felons, too

CA immigration marchAn immigration watchdog says it's not surprising that California's left-wing governor has pardoned a pair of illegal immigrants, one of them with a felony conviction for firearms possession.