Lawsuit demands Uncle Sam defend his rules for us

Friday, April 13, 2018
Chris Woodward (

U.S. Capitol 3A pair of lawsuits are demanding that the courts force the federal government to comply with a 1996 law that forces agencies to defend their own rules.

Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) filed the lawsuits asking the courts to force agencies to comply with the Congressional Review Act (CRA), a statute that Congress and President Bill Clinton approved in 1996 with the goal of restoring at least some degree of democratic accountability to the administrative state.

"Congress recognized that there was a problem of agencies having too much power and imposing rules on Americans across the country without any scrutiny from any of the people we elected to govern," says PLF attorney Jonathan.

EPA Environmental Protection Agency building"So the Congressional Review Act," he continues, "requires every new rule a bureaucrat wants to impose on you to first be submitted to Congress, where elected representatives have a chance to review it. And if they disapprove of the rule, to take the step of actually voiding it and preventing similar rules from being adopted in the future."

According to Wood, agencies have been terribly spotty in complying with the Congressional Review Act.

"Some agencies have faithfully submitted their rules to Congress for review. Others haven't done a very good job," he explains. "This is a problem that the White House and Congress have both warned agencies about, including last year when there was a hearing in the House. This is a really serious problem that the agencies need to get ahead of."

USDA logoOne of PLF's challenges involves controversial Sage Grouse Rules from the Departments of Interior and Agriculture in 2015. While the goal of the rules is to protect birds, PLF says the rules undermine widely supported state-led conservation efforts at the expense of those who rely on federal lands for their livelihoods.

The second of PLF's two challenges has to do with the PECE Rule from the Fish and Wildlife Service in 2003. PLF is representing a conservation group that has a plan to protect the Lesser Prairie Chicken, which is considered a "threatened" species.

Bureau of Land Management logo"But that plan depends on the incentives created by a rule by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service," he says. "The problem is that rule was never submitted to Congress and therefore can't be relied upon, which puts our clients in the impossible position of needing to do conservation but the service is undermining their efforts by having this rule in place that is not lawfully in effect and can't be relied upon."

The bottom line, Wood says, is the lawsuits would not be necessary if government, in this case agencies, did what they're told: follow the law.

Consider Supporting Us?

The staff at strives daily to bring you news from a biblical perspective. If you benefit from this platform and want others to know about it please consider a generous gift today.



We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details




Who would you prefer replace Paul Ryan as Speaker of the House?





  India prescribes death penalty for rape of kids under 12
  Hamas says man gunned down in Malaysia was important member
  Americans told to toss romaine lettuce over E. coli fears
  Dad stabbed to death as daughter sits in lap at restaurant
NKorea says it has suspended nuclear, missile testing
Israeli fire in new Gaza border protest kills 4 Palestinians
For Trump, Giuliani adds toughness, star power to legal team


After Texas governor slams NJ's high taxes, NJ governor responds
Trump blasts 'New York Times' reporter in tweetstorm
Bush family welcomes baby 2 days after Barbara Bush's death
Trump fires back on Twitter over Democrats' lawsuit
Previously deported illegal immigrant charged with attempted murder in nail gun attack


Cartoon of the Day


New emails show Hillary-FBI-DOJ coordination

Clinton email scandalNewly uncovered emails containing 22 messages with “Top Secret” information found on former Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton’s personal email server indicate that the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and Department of Justice (DOJ) “coordinated” efforts to devise a response to a major development in her email probe.