Immigration issue to blame for farm bill's failure

Monday, May 21, 2018
Chris Woodward (

farmer plowingWhile the House was not able to come together last week and approve a farm bill, it will happen. But one conservative wonders if Republicans are listening.

The House Freedom Caucus (HFC) wanted a vote on immigration policy. When that did not happen, the Freedom Caucus did not support the farm bill, and it failed after a vote of 198 to 213.

"The leadership cannot punish them now because they do present such a significant voting bloc," says Rachel Bovard of the Conservative Partnership Institute. "The farm bill will be brought up again, but in the meantime, there will be some furious rounds of negotiating between the leadership, the HFC to get to a middle ground, to get to a place that makes both sides happy. And then I assume the farm bill will pass at that point."


As for the Senate, the chamber is expected to want its own bill, and Bovard says senators are likely paying attention to some of the issues that have been raised in the House, which also include spending and work requirements for food stamps.

"Unfortunately, I don't think the farm bill is on a lot of minds in the Senate at this point," she adds. "But what they will notice is why the farm bill went down, and that's because of the immigration issue. And I think that may become a pressing question for the Senate as well before the mid-terms, just like it's going to in the House."

If, for some reason, the House and Senate cannot come together on a farm bill, the chambers will approve a temporary extension of the Obama-era bill.

'Separate the greedy from the needy'

Project 21, a network of black conservatives, supports language in the defeated bill that requires able-bodied adults on food stamps to work, train, or volunteer.

"The farm bill is all but a must-pass piece of legislation – and even though there are procedural problems in moving forward, it isn't something that's going to have to be let go," says Project 21 co-chair Horace Cooper.


"Our concern isn't the specific 'everything about the farm bill,' but the specific change that ensures that people who are receiving benefits and who are able-bodied actually are going to be required [to work, train, or volunteer]," he continues. "I know that that has had some controversy, but mostly from progressives. That's not in any way a contributor to the change in direction temporarily with the bill."

In a press release, Cooper says "we don't live in a world of unlimited resources [and] we absolutely must separate out the greedy from the needy. When those who are able to provide for themselves are not competing for help, the truly needy will find that substantially greater resources remain."

Eventually, says Cooper, Americans will see a farm bill passed – and he's hopeful it will be consistent with his group's "Blueprint for a Better Deal for Black America."

Consider Supporting Us?

The staff at strives daily to bring you news from a biblical perspective. If you benefit from this platform and want others to know about it please consider a generous gift today.



We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details




Would you prefer that Attorney General Jeff Sessions uphold the laws of the United States – or the laws of the United Methodist Church?





Man charged in bike path killings speaks in court of 'Allah'
Lawsuits challenge efforts to push abstinence-only on teens
Justices adopt digital-age privacy rules to track cellphones
Nearly 400 people used Calif. assisted death law in 2017
Trump tells GOP to 'stop wasting their time' on immigration
Supreme Court adopts new rules for cellphone tracking
UK split by Brexit divide 2 years after vote to leave EU


FBI agent Peter Strzok subpoenaed to testify by House Judiciary Committee
Trump shuts down federal office dictating guidelines for doctors
MT-Sen: Rosendale gets a boost from Trump Jr. as a new poll hits the campaign
Women-only tech scholarships, ‘Man Tax’ violate California discrimination laws: lawsuit
Boy, 13, charged with felony for recording meeting with principal


Cartoon of the Day


Prediction: Blackburn a likely winner in critical Senate race

Marsha Blackburn campaign ad stillA political analyst says despite what the polls are showing, conservative Congresswoman Marsha Blackburn should become the next U.S. senator from Tennessee.